Home Real Estate Ben Shapiro – Israeli-Palestinian Conflict [History lesson] (Part 3) | Reaction

Ben Shapiro – Israeli-Palestinian Conflict [History lesson] (Part 3) | Reaction

Avocado
-
50
Ben Shapiro – Israeli-Palestinian Conflict [History lesson] (Part 3) | Reaction

PortuguesePai’s reaction to “Here’s THE TRUTH About the Israeli-Palestinian Conflict (A Comprehensive History)”

Part 1 :
Part 2 :

Original Video :

►PortuguesePai Twitch :

Thank you all for watching! Stay tuned and SUBSCRIBE to the official PortuguesePai YouTube Channel to always be kept informed when I make a video or React to moments from games played on stream, to content put out across the interwebs.

source

50 COMMENTS

  3. First of all, I love your videos and at the beginning when you started touching on this topic of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, I said to myself, oh boy, where have you gotten yourself into, why couldn't you stay with the reaction to Peter's videos or songs
    But now I think it was a good idea in retrospect
    So to figure out what the hell is going on
    Here is a speech by a Lebanese Christian Arab woman
    That will be very helpful in understanding the situation
    https://youtu.be/w2jRahmBbBY

  12. I just want to say that while I enjoy your music reactions, I really especialy appreciate your honest and open perspective in learning more about our community. It is so refreshing to hear someone coming in with no preconceived notions, just trying to figure out the truth.
    Keep them coming! Thank you!!

  15. the gates on the roads happened during the lengthy terror waves, not sure exactly when but it was before the abraham accords and not really a major landmark in the conflict which is why it wasn't really mentioned here just like he did not mention many other incidents along the way, they built the border so that terrorist wouldn't have such easy access to attack
    i dont know if Ramadan is intended as the Yom kippur but could be, they have a month of fasting during the day
    i don't think what we saw last year is the last of it, people in israel always feel it festering low key and as long as that it happening we know there will be more war

  19. Why not build up the infrastructure? Because they want to keep the people poor because it suits their ends to destroy Israel. They can engender the Jew hatred in the population in Gaza. The leaders are just horrible people and the Gazans are held under their thrall.

  23. I love your reactions, whatever it is that you react to, music videos, history lessons, Peter's videos etc.
    I just wanted to say that i believe that most of us subscribed to your channel for the song reactions, and i personally really miss those. I thought that it might be a good idea that those days that you do a history lesson, etc, maybe you can do a song as well if it isn't too much?)
    <3

  26. I know that I'll be opening a can of worms here but there are a few opinions regarding the state of Israel and as you look at this from a few angles you might be interested in what the most of the Hasidic Rabbis that resided In Williamsburg and Borough Park believed there is a Channel called true Torah jews here is a link https://youtu.be/d3SJYRkI2hM they are not as represented as they believe that exposure never leads to a positive view (as history shows)

  31. Yayy, last part! As you say – let's jump right into it:
    2:25 – Iran calls the US "The Great Satan" and call Israel "The Little Satan".
    9:45 – Jews want to live in Judea and Samaria because there is a very important part of the history of the Kingdom of Israel. The Cave of the Patriarchs in Hebron was bought by Abraham our father to be a burial site for the ancestors – Abraham and Sarah, Isaac and Rebekah, Jacob and Leah. Rachel – the fourth mother – was buried near the city of Bethlehem, on Mount Ebal is the altar that Joshua built after he brought the people of Israel into the Land of Israel, the place of the tabernacle that the Israelites built when they entered the Land is in Shiloh, Nablus was the capital city of the Kingdom of Israel after the United Kingdom split into two – Kingdom Judah and the Kingdom of Israel and much more.In Judea and Samaria there are many archaeological sites from the history of the Land of Israel over different periods, and many events that took place in the Bible – there is evidence on the ground.
    Also – as Ben stated before, if we leave the area of Judea and Samaria, the entire state of Israel will be easily targeted and threatened by rockets and missiles that can easily reach any point, as you can see the narrow "sleeve" left to Israel.
    10:40 – Holy smokes… indeed why? Because we're Jews… That pretty much sums it up: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qgwRZjFwNYw
    And every time they manage to carry out an attack and kill Jews, they hand out sweets in the streets of Arab cities to celebrate the achievement.
    16:30 – Can I please say again that you seek sense in a place it doesn't exist? 😅 But seriously – the palestinians have an interest in maintaining their look as poor suffering people, that gains them the sympathy of the world against strong evil Israel, and most of all they receive donations and funding in very large amounts from European countries to help them, and then they have money to buy more weapons and ammunition.
    20:15 – Yup, it's a crazy world we live in…

    Now, can we go back a little to music pleeeeeeeeeeeease?
    But I said please…

  32. The only major thing I disagree with Ben is that he is saying that us Israelies don't want our ancient land in Jehuda and the Shomron and that really isn't the case. While we had prime ministers who offered those parts for peace, it wasn't publicly agreed upon.
    To answer your question about the walls, those walls were built after the Oslo Agreement, which gave the Arabs in those part an autonomy, as a separation measure against Intifada's and terror attacks (which wasn't very useful) . The checkposts you have seen in the previous videos are of Arabs who have A Palasitinic Autonomy citizenship (and not Israeli citizenship) but prefer to work in in the rest of Israel. Arabs who are Israel citizens live at the same side of the walls as the Jewish population and have the same civil rights.

  33. Like he said, whatever is going on in Israel is used as an excuse to attack Jews, who dont even know much about the Israeli Palestinian situation to be attacked. Just in the last few weeks where Peter Santinello walked through the streets , young teenage jewish boys , minding their own business were attacked by thugs yelling at them to "Free Palestine" and forcing the jewish boys to say "Free Palestine". Haters , will find every excuse to hate. Antisemites will find every excuse to blame Israel for whatever antisemitism is going on. Ironically , lots of us dont have any affiliation with Israel or understand the politics at all. I just got educated by watching your reaction video. But , I've been subjected to this antisemitic/anti zionistic behavior , just because I'm jewish and nothing else. Somehow my existence in this world is an excuse for violence towards people who only want peace and love amongst us. It's a messed up world.

  34. What a thought-provoking video! Thanks for that. It was clear and informative, though I did know, for the most part, this information. Listening to him laying it all out in a detailed fashion, was definitely interesting anyway. Excellent reaction video, as usual. Thanks!

  35. It’s a music video… but check out Ari Lesser’s Israel Apartheid.
    It combines music and your recent detour into the Israeli/Palestinian conflict.
    I think you might really enjoy it.

  38. 'Thank you , Thank you Thankyou Thankyou….. I personally can't thank you enough for watching this together with us. And especially your kindness and compassion in your understanding and reactions. You are spreading Light into the world. You are welcome to come and see all of the history Ben shared – together with your family and Stay in my home in Israel – You can sleep by us, and sit at our Shabbat Table and enjoy a slightly different kind of shabbat than Peter enjoyed. We are Orthodox and fully observant of Jewish Law – but not Hassidish so our value system is different. Also – the Jewish Laws regarding the "Land of Israel" – in terms of farming, growing crops, etc – apply only in Israel – That would be something fascinating for you to explore.

    BTW – Are you sure that you dont have Jewish ancestry in you???? Maybe your family background has some Marono heritage (Hidden /Secret Jews from Spain and Portugal – during the inquisition) ????? For example – Did your mother Lite candles on Friday night as a tradition – but didnt know why? any way, you are truly special.

  39. Its not subletting your house in sheich garach, it's jewish people legally owning their houses their, holding title for over a hundred years after purchasing it with money, and Arabs invading the houses illegally. The jewish owner wan to at least get rent for their owned houses which thr Arabs refuse to and attack

  41. History lesson
    TL;DR Jews can neither coexist, nor assimilate (they didn't for 2000 years), there's no way they'll coexist with Palestinians today

    The average age of a human being 50 years ago was 50 years, and even lower as we go back in time. If Jews were kicked out of their homeland 2000 years ago, 2000/50 makes it 40 generations (atleast). For 40 generations these people failed to assimilate, failed to naturalize, failed to live in harmony (coexist) with the people of the places they migrated to (remember countries didn't exist back then). If they can't learn to live in harmony in 40 generations, there's no way they will now (with Palestinians), and it would have been better if these people went extinct.

  44. every single thing he said is 100% historically accurate, but know that everyone speaks with an agenda (even good people) and he did skip some factors of the conflict… but this is basically more or less a quick rundown of the conflict… thanks for making this reaction!

  45. The Land of Palestine is mentioned many time in the old testament!!!

    Here is the best example the book of Genesis is was written before rome was founded!!!!

    Genesis 21:34
    And Abraham stayed in the land of the Philistines as a foreigner many days

    Also #Jerusalem, according to scientific research, has existed for about 4,000 years. During the first 1,000 years it had no connection to the #Jewish people. Even in the Bible, the Book of Hebrews tells about Melchizedek, the king of Salem, who came out to bless Abraham, who had no connection to Jerusalem. He was from Iraq…

    The Romans renamed the land back to its original name.

    Also
    In the 5th century BCE, the Greek historian Herodotus referred by name to Palestine as a land connecting Egypt and what is now Lebanon, inhabited by several peoples. These are only two examples of many texts that attest to an ancient and ongoing reference to the name Palestine

    You really need to check your information before you copy and paste Zioni$t false propaganda!!!!

    Also its Important point to always remember when addressing the propaganda line "There has never been a state of Palestine" — this is a trick. Nation states are a Western European concept that is relatively modern, a few hundred years in the case of Europe and barely a hundred years in other parts of the world. Palestine existed as a homeland, a country, a region, any semantic you want to use, for many many centuries, the fact it was not classified as a nation state the way modern western countries define that, is not relevant. Most of the world was not classified that way prior to a hundred years ago yet we do not go around saying China was never a state! Japan was a never a state! Etc. This line of thinking is pure propaganda.

  46. I think it is good that you have some of the basics understood now but for your sake i advise to not get too deep into this subject. Unless of course you are a politically inclined person beacuase it will get pretty intense.I watched you watch the video while pointing out reasonable points about the choices that are made by their leaders and thought how do you explain a reality where people actively choose every day war over peaceful and happy lives for their families. I am glad for you that you dont understand and that your reality is free from blind hatred so…thank you for wanting to be educated and informed but i think you should understand that there is no sanity in this. I am enjoying witnessing your journey and hope you are doing everything beacuase you are enjoying it too and not beacuase off feeling pressured or anything. How about listening to israeli songs that are really good but not covertly religious:))? take care

  47. Its never been easy to be a jew, being the chosen ones comes with a lot of responsibilities, The Lubavitcher Rebbe said, if we own up to the fact that in the Bible it sais that G-d gave Israel to the Jews it would end all this nonsense, untill Jews and Israel stand proud behind their Heritage we will be persecuted, it seems. unfortunately. May God sent the Mashiach now and bring peace for all of Humanity.

  48. Hi, it's so refreshing to see the innocent shock every time you see the unjustified violence going on. Through all these years we became already apathetic to the whole situation, and kind of got used to / normalize it.

    I actually live in Ashdod, we have 45 sec. to seek shelter. We kind of got used to having rockets fired at us every few months. "Routine". Thanks to the iron dome it became rare for rockets to fall, they're intercepted in the sky. (Have videos of that).

    Thanks for covering this topic, I do believe that Ben, history-wise, was very accurate, of course perspective-wise he's very pro Israel.
    The "apartheid" wall you're asking about, was built I think around the intifada era, where the israelis needed the security from arabs crossing from the west bank into Israel doing attacks.
    (There might be unjust in the way they regulate these areas, but the underlying rule is "security". If there were no security concerns, Israel wouldn't have any problem letting them live however they want. The problem is like one Israeli PM said, if the Palestinians layed down their weapons there would be no war, if Israel layed down it's weapons there would be no Israel.)

    P.s. as i stressed in a different comment there is a difference between the PLO, and the Palestinian people. I'm convinced that lots of them just want to live peacefully, with no violence. That's what you'll see in the jubilee video.

    Edit: Example of a fresh message from Hamas leaders from today:
    Senior Hamas official Muhammad Deif on the 35th anniversary of the founding of Hamas: "We must unite all areas for a noble goal – the liberation of Palestine". In addition, Hamas leader Sinuar calls on all Palestinians in the West Bank to carry out terrorist attacks in Israel".

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

© Newspaper WordPress Theme by TagDiv