Home Real Estate Why shipping container homes are overrated

Why shipping container homes are overrated

28
Why shipping container homes are overrated

They’re fun. They’re also way more difficult to build than they seem.

Subscribe and turn on notifications 🔔 so you don’t miss any videos:

Shipping container homes have been a trend for a while, from reality TV shows to housing policy discussions. But the truth is that these homes are a lot more difficult to build than you might think.

It’s easy to think that housing solutions are purely technological, but many obstacles to housing aren’t in construction but in the policies surrounding homebuilding. Moreover, many of the supposed advantages of shipping containers turn out to be more complicated in reality.

Vox’s Phil Edwards spent a night in a shipping container home to see how the experience of staying in a shipping container compares with the reality of building one.

Further Reading:

Mark Hogan’s 2015 opinion piece about shipping containers is a great introduction to the topic:
Belinda Carr’s debunking of shipping containers gets into more building science detail:
She’s also an even-handed critic and made a video about five shipping container successes:
You can check out Michael’s Airbnbs here:

Make sure you never miss behind-the-scenes content in the Vox Video newsletter, sign up here:

Vox.com is a news website that helps you cut through the noise and understand what’s really driving the events in the headlines. Check out

Support Vox’s reporting with a one-time or recurring contribution:

Shop the Vox merch store:

Watch our full video catalog:

Follow Vox on Facebook:
Follow Vox on Twitter:
Follow Vox on TikTok:

source

28 COMMENTS

  1. I saw the title and I thought "is this going to be a rip off of Belinda Carr's video?" And was pleasantly surprised when you featured her in the video.

  2. The problem with a lot of these "affordable" solutions such as shipping containers and 3D printed houses is the only thing they really eliminate from normal house construction is the framing step, which in the grand scheme of things is not even that expensive when it comes to house construction.

  3. I'm not someone who understands about housing, but if you look from the other side of the world where the rules for building a house and the necessities of life are not as complicated as shown in the video, maybe Container is an easy and cheap option

  4. I'm not sure which architecture school she went to, but when I was at architecture school there was not a focus on modularity and to make everything modular. There was one studio professor who who did offer one course in that, but only 12 people took it per year. In addition, my architecture school did teach us how to put in real life elements such as plumbing, electrical and heating, and doors and windows.

  5. Belinda is kind of an egomaniac. But I love how she takes time to look into the math and economics of each topic she talks about to provide you with factual evidence.

  6. The fact of the matter is, as a starting point they are unbeatable. Plus this vid infers that this is a new concept and that there isn't a legacy of SC home builders who share their knowledge. In my research, nobody I've spoken to, regrets SC's as the building blocks for their homes. As for insulation, it can and has been done a lot cheaper than the options mentioned here. Struts to compensate for additional weight at places the container wasn't designed to bear weight on, like a 4×4 steel tube beam. As for foundations, it depends on the state, (US), some states require you to bore and cast a concrete or similar, set of legs or plinths, other states are satisfied with a bed of sand or gravel and railway ties.
    Home owners dont like them, who see this as a threat to the value of their homes.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here